Kalshi Politics — Mispricing Audit (Anchor, NO-side structural)

Report date 2026-10-13 · strategy=Anchor · audit_version=anchor · category focus Politics · horizon 45 days · capital $2,500

1. Summary

One pick, 37 logged rejects, $124.96 deployed (5.0% of capital), $2,375.04 (95.0%) held in cash.

The Stage-0 allowlist (120 series, 702 open markets) yields only 37 markets closing inside the 45-day horizon, and the market has already priced the status quo to 95¢+ on nearly all of them. After the mechanical cuts (volume, spread, 5¢/95¢ edges, 7-day rule, continuous-number and Mentions filters) three markets reached Stage 2: the Bank of Canada October hike leg, the Bank of Canada hold leg, and the Lisa Cook "try to fire" rung. Kimberly Guilfoyle's resignation today (Oct 13) settled the Greece-ambassador market in fact but at 96/97 it is in the deep-favorite band.

The single survivor is NO on "Will the President try to fire Lisa Cook before Nov 1, 2026?" at 88¢, a status-quo thesis anchored on the President's own calendar: the Oct 7 memorandum fixes the committee hearing for Nov 5, four days after this rung closes. It sits in the 85–89¢ thin-favorites band, so it deploys at half size. The edge is thin (about 2¢) and is stated as such.

Zero-to-one picks is the expected Anchor output in a week where the NO side is already fully priced. Cash is a position; 95% cash is the correct result here, not a failure to find trades.

2. Suggested portfolio — position sizes and limits

TickerSideLimitContractsCost (max loss)Max winConvictionBandCluster
KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26NOV01NO88¢142$124.96$17.04MEDIUM85–89¢ thin favorite → half size (5%)cook-fed-removal-process
Cash reserve$2,375.0495.0% of capital (minimum reserve is 10%)

3. Pick card

Mechanism: status-quoBUY NO @ 88¢Conviction: mediummulti-news-other

Trump tries to fire Fed Gov. Lisa Cook before Nov 1, 2026?

KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26NOV01 · closes 2026-11-01T15:00:00Z · resolver: Kalshi, per rules_secondary list of qualifying acts

YES condition. For YES to pay, between this rung's issuance (Oct 8, 2026 19:43Z) and Nov 1, 2026 15:00Z the President must sign a termination document, direct an official to terminate Cook, publicly state he has fired or decided to fire her, have the White House announce termination, send her a termination letter, or initiate formal legal proceedings for removal, as judged by Kalshi. Success of the attempt is irrelevant.

Thesis. Status quo: the President's own committee hearing on Cook is set for Nov 5, four days after this rung closes, so a YES needs Trump to blow up his own SCOTUS-mandated process before his own hearing.

Probability. 10% pre-market → 10% final for YES (book 12/14). Fair NO ≈ 90¢; fillable NO 88¢ for 1,902 contracts.

Vehicle and calendar (primary sources). whitehouse.gov, Presidential Memorandum of Oct 7, 2026, "Establishment of a Committee of Inquiry to Investigate Allegations of False Statements by Lisa DeNell Cook": the committee (Hassett, Sonderling, Lucas) "shall, on November 5, 2026, conduct an in-person hearing" at the White House of no more than four hours; Cook may file a post-hearing statement by Nov 10; the committee then reports findings and "shall recommend whether there is cause to remove." The Supreme Court's June 29, 2026 ruling in Trump v. Cook requires notice and a hearing before removal (CNBC Oct 9; PBS Oct 9). Cook's counsel (Lowell, Eisen) said they are "engaged with the White House to evaluate whether the process proposed has a possibility of being a genuine one." No step of this process lands before Nov 1.

Precedents consulted. KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26OCT01 (settled NO Oct 1, 2026): "the clock starts at each rung's own issuance, so a pre-issuance action never pays"; the Oct 7 memo pre-dates this rung's Oct 8 issuance. KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26SEP01 (settled NO): "monthly TRYFIRE rungs after a court loss are status-quo NO until the President has a lawful path; the process steps (memo, hearing) land on dates you can read off whitehouse.gov." Edge note on the Oct 1 rung: Cook's counsel cite Trump's "repeated statements that he has already decided to fire" her, yet no such statement resolved the Sep 1 or Oct 1 rung, so the resolver's bar for the "decided to fire" clause is above Trump's rhetoric.

Resolver profile and risk pricing. Resolver is Kalshi applying an enumerated list; the market closes early on a qualifying act. Deductions: (a) Kalshi retroactively reads the Oct 7/9 memorandum as "initiating formal legal proceedings," ~3 pts (the market has traded five days and 32k contracts on Oct 11 without an early close, and the sister Dec 1 rung trades 38/45, which it would not if the memo paid); (b) an ambiguous "she'll be gone" remark read as "decided to fire," ~3 pts; (c) impulsive on-record firing statement before the hearing, ~4 pts. Total ≈ 10 pts, under the 15-pt reject line.

Cleanest tail. A new discrete event: Trump posts or says on camera that Cook is fired or that he has decided to fire her before Nov 5, abandoning the due-process cure his own lawyers built after losing at the Supreme Court. This is not a trend continuing; the trend (process, hearing, report) runs past the deadline. Priced in the 10%.

48h move and book. YES spiked to 40–53¢ on Oct 10 and ran 16–40¢ on Oct 11 (32k contracts) as traders debated whether the memo's Oct 9 publication qualified, then settled to 12–14¢ on Oct 12–13 once no early close came. Specialist-dense book (vol24h 17,117; OI 59,589), which is why size is held to the half-size band cap rather than the depth cap (1/3 of 1,902 = 634).

Entry YES bid/ask 12 / 14
NO fillable 88¢ × 1,902
Vol 24h 17,117
Open interest 59,589
Edge +2¢ (fair NO 90)
EV +2.3% gross; ≈ +1.5% after ~0.7¢ fee

4. EV for the record

TickerSidePriceP(YES) pre → finalFair (side)EdgeEV/contractEV %ContractsExpected $
KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26NOV01NO88¢10% → 10%90¢+2¢+2.0¢+2.3%142+$2.84

Sizing is flat and EV-agnostic (Anchor): 10% of capital per pick, 5% in the 85–89¢ band, then the depth cap. EV is recorded for the scoreboard only.

5. Cluster table

ClusterLegs consideredDeployed legNote
cook-fed-removal-process26NOV01 (NO), 26DEC01 (NO, outside horizon)26NOV01 NODec 1 rung contains the Nov 5 hearing and the committee report; genuine coin flip, not Anchor-shaped.
boc-oct28-decisionH25 (NO), H0 (YES), C25/C26/H26 (Stage-0)noneH25 NO fillable 86–88¢ vs fair ~81¢: negative edge. H0 YES is a yes-side thesis.
guilfoyle-greece-exit26NOV01 (YES)noneResigned Oct 13; 96/97 is deep-favorite band.
zacharia-presssec-exit26OCT20, 26OCT24, 26NOV01 (NO)noneDeep-favorite band or 11¢ spread on a day-old book.
suez-weekly-count8 rungsnoneContinuous-number ladder, inside 7d.

6. Risk profile

7. Execution notes

8. Rejected markets (logged, scoreable)

Every market inside the 45-day horizon that reached Stage 0 or beyond. Side and price are what Anchor would have taken; probability is the final YES estimate (market mid where not researched).

TickerSidePriceP(YES)ClusterReason
KXCBDECISIONCANADA-26OCT-H25
Will Bank of Canada Hike rates by 25bps at their October 2026 meeting?
NO86¢19%boc-oct28-decisioninside spread: fillable NO is 86c for 49 contracts then 87-88c, vs fair NO ~81c (P(hike) 18% pre-market -> 19% final; CORRA OIS 27% hike on Oct 13 per BlueGamma; Sep 2 statement two-sided 'prepared to adjust'; LFS Oct 9 -68k jobs, UE 6.5%; Sep CPI lands Oct 19 inside the window). Negative edge, and the tail is oil pass-through continuing into a hot Oct 19 CPI (continuation tail).
KXCBDECISIONCANADA-26OCT-H0
Will Bank of Canada Hike rates by 0bps at their October 2026 meeting?
YES84¢80%boc-oct28-decisionyes-side thesis: a hold-YES forecasts the content of a scheduled decision, not a dated step that itself pays; neither already-happened nor process-in-motion. YES ask 84c vs 80% final (78% pre-market; OIS hold 73%). NO at 16c is below band. Precedent 26JUL-H0/26JUN-H0: hold leg is 1-3c carry, 'stop calling it a pick'.
KXGUILFOYLEOUT-26OCT-26NOV01
Will Kimberly Guilfoyle be out as US Ambassador to Greece before Nov 1, 2026?
YES97¢96%guilfoyle-greece-exitdeep-favorite band: Guilfoyle resigned Oct 13, 2026 at the White House's request (CNBC, Axios, Washington Times, Oct 13) and the rules pay on the actual vacate date; YES 96/97 is above the 90c cap and fails the Stage-0 YES bid >= 95c cut. Already-happened shape, but no band left.
KXZACHARIAOUT-26OCT-26NOV01
Will Katie Zacharia be out as White House Press Secretary before Nov 1, 2026?
NO95¢4%zacharia-presssec-exitinside spread: book opened Oct 13 and is 11c wide (YES 5/16); NO fillable only at 95c, which is also deep-favorite band. No vehicle for a departure; she announced the Guilfoyle exit today.
KXZACHARIAOUT-26OCT-26OCT24
Will Katie Zacharia be out as White House Press Secretary before Oct 24, 2026?
NO96¢3%zacharia-presssec-exitdeep-favorite band: YES 4/6 -> NO 94-96c (>=90c). Status quo already fully priced.
KXTRYFIRECOOK-27JAN01-26DEC01
Will the President try to fire the Lisa Cook as member of the Board of Governors
NO62¢45%cook-fed-removal-processoutside horizon: closes Dec 1 (49 days). Not researched; the Nov 5 hearing and post-Nov 10 committee report sit inside this window, so it is a genuine coin flip rather than an Anchor shape. Same cluster as the pick.
KXDIESELEXPORTBAN-26
Will it be reported that a US diesel export ban is in effect before Nov 3, 2026?
NO95¢6%diesel-export-banalready an active pick (EXISTING_PICKS: KXDIESELEXPORTBAN-26 NO). NO now 92-95c, deep-favorite band anyway.
KXIPOANTHROPIC-DATE-26OCT17
When will Anthropic officially announce an IPO?
NO100¢0%anthropic-ipo-timingStage-0 mechanical: inside 7d; volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXZACHARIAOUT-26OCT-26OCT20
Will Katie Zacharia be out as White House Press Secretary before Oct 20, 2026?
NO97¢3%zacharia-presssec-exitStage-0 mechanical: inside 7d; YES ask 4c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T330
Will there be more than 330 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO96¢5%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T320
Will there be more than 320 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO91¢9%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T310
Will there be more than 310 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO80¢20%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; volume24h 0 < 500.
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T300
Will there be more than 300 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO72¢28%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; volume24h 12 < 500.
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T290
Will there be more than 290 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO55¢45%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; volume24h 0 < 500.
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T280
Will there be more than 280 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO42¢58%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d; volume24h 4 < 500.
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T270
Will there be more than 270 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO20¢81%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d.
KXSUEZWEEKLY-26OCT18-T260
Will there be more than 260 transit calls through the Suez Canal from Oct 12, 20
NO9¢91%suez-weekly-countStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (weekly transit-count ladder); inside 7d.
KXIPOANTHROPIC-DATE-26OCT24
When will Anthropic officially announce an IPO?
NO100¢0%anthropic-ipo-timingStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXCBDECISIONCANADA-26OCT-H26
Will Bank of Canada Hike rates by >25bps at their October 2026 meeting?
NO100¢0%boc-oct28-decisionStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 35 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXCBDECISIONCANADA-26OCT-C26
Will Bank of Canada Cut rates by >25bps at their October 2026 meeting?
NO100¢0%boc-oct28-decisionStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXCBDECISIONCANADA-26OCT-C25
Will Bank of Canada Cut rates by 25bps at their October 2026 meeting?
NO99¢1%boc-oct28-decisionStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 65 < 500; YES ask 2c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXJUDGECOUNT-26OCT-0
Will any federal judges be confirmed in Oct 2026?
NO100¢0%kxjudgecount-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: continuous-number market (confirmation count); volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXLEAVEMERZ-29JAN01-26NOV01
Will Friedrich Merz leave Chancellor of Germany before Nov 1, 2026?
NO100¢1%kxleavemerz-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 3c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXKASHOUT-26JUL-26NOV01
Will Kash Patel be out as FBI Director before Nov 1, 2026?
NO100¢0%patel-exitStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 1c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXLEAVEPOWELLGOV-26NOV01
Will Jerome Powell leave Member of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
NO100¢2%kxleavepowellgov-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 4c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXMARTINDNCOUT-26MAY-26NOV01
Will Ken Martin be out as chair of the Democratic National Committee before Nov
NO98¢5%kxmartindncout-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; spread 6c > 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXIPOANTHROPIC-DATE-26NOV01
When will Anthropic officially announce an IPO?
NO99¢1%anthropic-ipo-timingStage-0 mechanical: YES ask 2c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXDJTATTACKWARSH-26SEP-26NOV01
Will Trump publicly criticize Kevin Warsh before Nov 1, 2026?
NO95¢6%kxdjtattackwarsh-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: Mentions-type market ('will X say Y'); volume24h 10 < 500; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXHEGSETHOUT-26AUG-26NOV01
Will Pete Hegseth be out as Secretary of Defense before Nov 1, 2026?
NO98¢2%hegseth-exitStage-0 mechanical: YES ask 3c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXNETANYAHUPARDON-26-NOV01
Will Benjamin Netanyahu be pardoned before Nov 1, 2026?
NO99¢3%kxnetanyahupardon-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXUSAIRANAGREEMENT-27-26NOV
Will the US agree to a new Iranian nuclear deal this year?
NO99¢1%kxusairanagreement-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: YES ask 2c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXDEMSCHUMER-27-NOV03
Will any current member of the Democratic Senate caucus (including independents
NO87¢15%kxdemschumer-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 5 < 500.
KXLEAVEDUNN
Will Neal Dunn leave Congress before the midterms?
NO94¢7%kxleavedunn-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXMILLEROUT-26JUL-26NOV03
Will Max Miller be out as U.S. representative before Nov 3, 2026?
NO98¢2%kxmillerout-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: YES ask 3c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXRETIREMM-26
Will Mitch McConnell resign his office early?
NO99¢1%kxretiremm-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: YES ask 2c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXRETIREPELOSI-26
Will Nancy Pelosi resign her office early?
NO99¢1%kxretirepelosi-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 0 < 500; YES ask 2c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).
KXFETTERMANSWITCH-26MAY-NOV03
Will John Fetterman leave the Democratic party before Nov 3, 2026?
NO99¢2%kxfettermanswitch-status-quoStage-0 mechanical: volume24h 20 < 500; YES ask 3c <= 5c; deep-favorite band (NO >= 90c).

9. Universe and method notes

Generated by Claude (Anchor methodology) · 1 pick · 37 rejects · $124.96 allocated of $2,500.