Kalshi Politics — Mispricing Audit (v4, archetype-targeted, precedent-fed)

Report date 2026-08-06 · Horizon 45 days · Capital $10,000 · Universe: targets.json (117 allowlisted series, generated 2026-08-06 12:06 UTC)

Summary

1 pick, 4 logged rejects, $92.66 deployed (0.9% of capital), 99.1% cash. The 45-day slate was structurally thin: 51 open allowlisted markets survived the horizon filter, but the live-book liquidity floor (vol24h ≥ 500) and price-bound cuts left only 3 candidates — the market's attention this week is concentrated on the Senate's final pre-recess sprint. The single deployment is the Tier-1 confirmation/enact leg the week actually offers: Todd Blanche's AG confirmation before Sep 1, with cloture already filed and a two-defection failure bar the headlines misdescribe as one. Cash is a position; an efficient thin week correctly produces one small pick.

Candidates
3 of 51
Picks
1
Rejects logged
4
Deployed
$92.66
Cash
99.1%
Reserve rule (≥10%)
Met

Pick 1 — Blanche confirmed as AG before Sep 1 · BUY YES

KXAGCONF-26JUN05-SEP01

confirmation/enact Tier 1 MEDIUM conviction

“Will Trump's first announced Attorney General pick be confirmed as Attorney General before Sep 1, 2026?” · closes 2026-09-01 03:59 UTC

Prob (pre-market)
86%
Prob (final)
84%
Entry (YES ask)
81¢
Limit
82¢
Contracts
113
Max cost
$92.66

Thesis. The process is mechanically in motion, 24 days inside the deadline. Judiciary advanced Todd Blanche (acting AG since April; nominated off the June 5 announcement — the ticker stem) 12–10 on Aug 4, with committee holdouts Tillis and Cornyn aboard after Blanche rescinded the “anti-weaponization fund” (NPR, The Hill, Aug 3). Thune filed cloture at 10:47am on Aug 5 (Senate Daily Press floor record), ripening to a Friday Aug 7 cloture vote and a Saturday Aug 8 final vote (Punchbowl timeline) — the last acts before August recess.

The mispricing. With 53R–47D, McConnell absent, and Collins a declared NO, 99 senators vote and 48 NOs are locked: failure needs both undecideds — Murkowski and Cassidy — to defect (one defection still confirms 50–49; the VP tiebreak is moot with 99 voting). Broadcast framing (“hanging by a thread,” “either could sink it”) describes single-defector risk the arithmetic doesn't support, and an 80–81¢ book looks priced to that scarier framing. Majority leaders essentially never carry a cabinet nominee to a floor vote and lose — zero floor defeats across this administration, with Hegseth (51–50) the surviving worst case. Residual real risk: both defect, or Thune pulls the vote into September (recess runs past Sep 1) — I price the union at ~15%.

Precedents consulted: KXAGCONF-26-JUL01 resolved NO — “first announced pick” keys to the current vacancy via the ticker stem (26JUN05 = Blanche), not any earlier withdrawn nominee. KXAGCONF-26-JUN15 resolved NO — price the confirmation clock from Senate transmittal with a ~5–6 week floor; that clock has now fully run (announced June 5, committee cleared, cloture filed).

Resolver profile & risk pricing (Stage 2.5). Resolver is Kalshi against the official Senate roll-call record — single-official, no interpretation gap. Rules_secondary carries a dated clarification: “If a nomination is withdrawn before the deadline, that market immediately resolves to No” — the resolver's reading given in advance. Deductions: withdrawal-before-vote −2 pts (overlaps the whip-count failure path); competing “first person confirmed” nominee −0 (none exists). Total −2 pts, well under the 15-pt reject line. Prob: 86% pre-market → 84% final (deduction applied, then blended toward a liquid 80/81 book).

Entry context & sizing. Book at fetch: 80.0 / 81.0, vol24h 14,325 (specialist-dense — edge demanded and stated above), OI 42,149. Visible YES liquidity at ≤82¢ is only ~340 contracts (260 @ 81, 79 @ 82) — the depth cap (⅓ of visible) binds at 113 contracts, far below the MEDIUM cap (7% = $700). Max cost $92.66. Slippage ≤ 3¢ satisfied. 48h check: price has held 78–85 since the Aug 3 committee repricing; entry is not chasing a spike.

Rejects (logged)

MarketArchetypeSide/PxProbReason
KXPIRROOUT-26AUG-26SEP01
Pirro announces departure as US Atty (DC) before Sep 1
multi-news-otherNO @ 70¢31% public-info-only Whipsawed 97¢→30¢ in 48h (Oval Office blowup Aug 3 → Trump “haven't made a determination,” Aug 5). Prob 35% pre-market → 31% final; both sides now within 1–4 pts of fair. YES @ 31¢ is also a sub-40¢ tail-band reject. Departure/ouster precedent (KXKASHOUT, KXLUTNICKOUT): presidential displeasure without an affirmative removal signal or named successor doesn't resolve YES.
KXJUDGECOUNT-26AUG-1
≥2 federal judges confirmed in Aug 2026
confirmation/enactNO @ ~95¢8% band Band-locked both sides: YES ask 10¢ (<40¢ tail), NO ~95¢ (≥90¢ deep favorite). Final pre-recess floor time is consumed by the CR, Blanche, and the college-sports bill (Senate Daily Press, Aug 5); the four pending judicial nominees slip to September, outside the window.
KXPIRROOUT-26AUG-26AUG07
Pirro out before Aug 7
multi-news-other— @ 4/5¢ mechanical YES ask ≤ 5¢ (near-resolved); cluster sibling of the Sep 1 leg, itself rejected.
KXHEGSETHOUT-26APR-SEP01
Hegseth out as SecDef before Sep 1
multi-news-other already an active pick Hard rule: $EXISTING_PICKS tickers never re-pick.

Stage 0 — Universe & mechanical cuts

51 open markets in allowlisted series close within the 45-day horizon. Mechanical cuts (live book, not file snapshots): 42 failed the vol24h ≥ 500 floor (the zero-volume-book rule from the resolved record), 5 were near-resolved (YES ask ≤ 5¢: KXALITOOUT, KXKASHOUT Sep rungs, KXUSAIRANAGREEMENT, KXCOMPANYACTIONMERGER, KXIPOANTHROPIC), 1 was a deep favorite (KXCBDECISIONMEXICO HOLD @ 98 bid), and 1 was an existing pick (Hegseth). Survivors: KXAGCONF-26JUN05-SEP01, KXJUDGECOUNT-26AUG-1, KXPIRROOUT-26AUG-26SEP01 — all three worked through Stages 1–3.5 above.

Position sizes & limits

MarketSideLimitContractsMax cost% of capitalCap that bound
KXAGCONF-26JUN05-SEP01YES82¢113$92.660.93%Depth (⅓ × 340 visible ≤ 82¢)
Cash$9,907.3499.07%

EV for the record

MarketEntry (worst)Model probEdgeEV / $1 at risk
KXAGCONF-26JUN05-SEP01 YES82¢84%+2–3¢+2.4%

Sizing is EV-agnostic and conviction-tiered per v4; EV shown for the record only. Kalshi taker fee ≈ 1.1¢/contract at this price is not included in EV but is noted in execution.

Cluster table

ClusterDeployed legRunner-up legs (logged)
blanche-ag-confirmationKXAGCONF-26JUN05-SEP01 YESnone in horizon
pirro-departurenone (rejected)KXPIRROOUT-26AUG-26AUG07, KXPIRROOUT-26AUG-26SEP01
aug-judicial-confirmationsnone (rejected)KXJUDGECOUNT-26AUG-1 (the -3 and -4 strikes failed Stage-0 volume)

Conviction exposure & risk profile

ConvictionPositionsCostCap
HIGH0$015% / pick
MEDIUM1$92.667% / pick ($700)

Risk profile. Single-name, single-cluster exposure of 0.93% of capital; max loss $92.66 if Murkowski and Cassidy both defect (or the vote is pulled into September). The position wins ≈ $21 net of fees if Blanche confirms Friday/Saturday. No continuous-number theses, no ≥90¢ legs, no second legs on one thesis. Worst realistic drawdown equals max cost.

Execution notes

Methodology notes (v4 discipline check)